Hands-On Review of the Best Budget XLR Microphones

Best Budget XLR Microphone for Vocals: A Hands-On Review of the Audio-Technica AT2020 and Shure SM58

Estimated reading time: 5 minutes

  • Two top budget options: Audio-Technica AT2020 and Shure SM58
  • AT2020: Best for studio recording with clear audio clarity
  • SM58: Ideal for live performances with rugged durability
  • Consider your needs: Subtlety vs. robustness in mic choice
  • Explore more gear: Recommended setups from Geeksper

Table of Contents

Testing Set-Up

Before jumping into my personal tests, I set up a simple yet effective rig: a Focusrite Scarlett 2i2 audio interface, a decent pair of studio monitors, and a mixing board. The goal? Capture clear vocal recordings while comparing these mics head-to-head. Spanning different recording scenarios—like singing, podcasting, and general voice-overs—I wanted to understand the strengths and weaknesses of each mic.

The Audio-Technica AT2020

Specs and Features Overview:
– Type: Condenser
– Polar Pattern: Cardioid
– Price: Usually under $100
– Best For: Studio vocal recording, podcasts, voice-overs
– Strengths: Excellent audio clarity, reliable high sound pressure level handling, wide frequency response

First Impressions:
The AT2020 greets you with a sturdy build that feels just right. It’s not the flashy type, but the matte finish gives it a classy vibe. Right after connecting it, I noticed it required phantom power. Had I not read up before, I might have been in for a surprise. After powering it up, the mic performs in a way that immediately justified its status as a go-to for many creators.

Vocal Performance:
I started with some spoken word. Switching off the gain on my interface, I discovered the mic needed a bit more juice than I expected. Turning it up to around 75% unlocked its full potential—rich, balanced tones with nice highs and lows. But, if I started talking too softly, the mic struggled to pick up the nuances—a classic condenser quirk. However, once I dialed in a consistent speaking level, I was impressed by its detail and clarity.

The Shure SM58

Specs and Features Overview:
– Type: Dynamic
– Polar Pattern: Cardioid
– Price: Around $99–$110
– Best For: Live and studio vocals
– Strengths: Rugged durability, ambient noise rejection, smooth vocal presence

First Impressions:
Unboxing the SM58 felt a bit like stepping into the world of legendary performers. It’s heavy, the construction screams durability, and there’s just something reassuring about its design. Instantly, I knew this mic was built for rough handling, whether in a live setting or a home studio.

Vocal Performance:
Moving to the SM58, I was immediately struck by the directness of the sound. There’s no mistaking this as an industry standard for live performances. I tried some singing, and while it didn’t have the same airy quality as the AT2020, it excelled in delivering a punchy mid-range presence that feels great for vocals. I felt almost invincible as I belted out (probably poorly) my favorite tunes.

The downside? This mic doesn’t have the same sensitivity to nuance as a condenser does. You have to really work the mic by getting closer to it. But with that trade-off comes a robust nature—less feedback and ambient noise interference, making it much friendlier in loud environments.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Audio Quality
– AT2020: Detailed high-end response; sounds airy and open. Great for nuanced vocals, but can pick up background noise easily.
– SM58: Robust sound with a focus on mid-range tones; handles loud inputs well and offers better noise rejection.

Build Quality
– AT2020: Sturdy but feels more delicate compared to the SM58.
– SM58: Built like a tank. I could probably drop it and pick it up without worry.

Use Cases
– AT2020: Perfect for studio environments and where subtleties are essential. Think polished podcasts and crisp vocals.
– SM58: The go-to for live performances, outdoor events, and any scenario where rough handling may occur.

Additional Comparisons

Other Budget Choices
While my main focus was on the AT2020 and SM58, there are other microphones worth considering depending on your needs:

  • Audio-Technica ATR2100x: This dual-output dynamic microphone offers flexibility with both USB and XLR connections, making it fantastic for home studios or streaming setups.
  • t.bone MB 7 Beta: If you’re really on a tight budget, this entry-level dynamic mic aims to mimic the sound of the Shure SM7B for significantly less.
  • Beyerdynamic M70 PRO X: Provides a broadcast-style sound and somewhat priced similarly to the AT2020.
  • Rode NT1-A: Higher on the budget scale but renowned for its stunning low noise, great for music recording.

Practical Takeaways

After spending quality time with both the Audio-Technica AT2020 and Shure SM58, here’s a consolidated take:

  1. Choose the AT2020 if you need ultimate clarity and detail in a more controlled environment. It’s excellent for those seeking to record vocal performances that shine in studio recordings or crisp podcasts.
  2. Opt for the SM58 if you want something durable that can handle the rough and tumble of live performances while still sounding great in the studio.

It’s a straightforward distinction—condenser mics like the AT2020 shine in controlled settings where sound precision matters, while dynamic mics like the SM58 thrive in varied environments, providing reliability and durability.

Conclusion

In summary, if you’re trying to find the best budget XLR microphone for vocals, both the Audio-Technica AT2020 and Shure SM58 come highly recommended—each an industry benchmark in its right. The AT2020 is perfect for studio dynamics and crisp recording needs, while the SM58 is a trustworthy workhorse for live settings and robust vocal demands.

Which one suits your needs? It largely depends on whether you prioritize fine detail or rugged durability. If you’re serious about laying down tracks or starting your podcast, you can’t go wrong with these great options.

If you’re curious to dive deeper into your own audio setup, check out Geeksper’s recommended gear here.

Ready to invest in your vocal clarity? Explore your options further and perhaps grab that budget XLR mic today!

FAQ

What type of microphone is better for studio recording?
The Audio-Technica AT2020 is generally considered better for studio recordings due to its clarity and sensitivity in capturing nuanced sounds.

Can the Shure SM58 be used in the studio?
Yes, the Shure SM58 can also be used in the studio, but it excels more in live settings where its rugged design offers advantages.

Are there any other budget-friendly microphones worth considering?
Yes, options like the Audio-Technica ATR2100x and t.bone MB 7 Beta are great alternatives for those on a budget.